The Hike

The Hike by Drew Magary

In 1949, Joseph Campbell published The Hero with a Thousand Faces, where he catalogues a bunch of ancient myths whose protagonists leave the known for the unknown and then return to the known some indeterminate amount of time later a changed individual. Campbell's intention was to cherrypick these myths in such a way that he would be presenting a Grand Unifying Theory about the origin and anthropology of all mythology. What he actually did was write a novel-length and -formatted group of TVTropes articles long before that website existed. Appropriately, the "monomyth" that Campbell was proposing was commented on by future scholars as a trope titled "The Hero's Journey", which is indeed what the TVTropes page calls it today.

Why does this distinction matter? Well, to give a tongue-in-cheek metaphorical answer: it's like a science fair volcano, wherin the thing being exhibited is a reaction between baking soda and vinegar as opposed to accurately modeling a volcanic eruption. In a more practical sense: the picture Campbell aimed to paint was one where every culture all over the world had their own separate oral traditions traced back to a purportedly nonfictional origin story, wheras the reality was that epic poets were more concerned about Remembering Some Heroes in service of telling a good story. These stories, despite being passed down originally as oral tradition, apply literary tools which literary-minded individuals would later comment on as "tropes".

Now that a trope has been commented on, subsequent writers can now play with the concept when storyboarding. You are probably familiar with the story that George Lucas intentionally invoked The Hero's Journey when storyboarding Luke Skywalker's character arc in the original Star Wars trilogy. Closer to the present day, Drew Magary sits down at a dask with a typewriter and a bare lamppost. The lampshade he decides to hang is that "Hero's Journey" infographic that educators love to use annotated with notes about how to parody the concept as opposed to playing it straight. This is, in broad strokes, the genesis of The Hike and Ben's character arc within.

Ben, an unassuming salaryman, has his call to adventure into the unknown come in the form of tire tracks that extend past the officially marked end of a hiking trail behind the hotel he's staying at. If the initial run-in with dog-faced attackers didn't clue Ben into the fact that getting back to the known won't be easy, an ominious piece of stationary in a tent does the trick (emphasis mine):

Stay on the path, or you will die.

"The path" and references to it are the arc words of this book. There are layers to this phrase. First off, the path and its associated trials can be likened to The Hero's Journey. Additionally, the path may as well extend indefinitely from Ben's point of view as he goes through it, so comparisons to the path towards escaping the endless cycle of death and rebirth are appropriate. What lies at the end of this cycle? A run-in with an enigmatic "Producer". The presence of a Producer figure ties these layers full circle, both as an analogue to the divine intervention that drives stories from classical mythology and to the present-day jobs driving the production of shows and films.

The choice of a crab as the most irreverent of Ben's mentor/companion figures on this hike seems to have come out of left field at first glance. The reveal that Crab is Ben from a point further along the path (which we do eventually end up seeing for ourselves) is a nod to carcinisation, the phenomenon that all shellfish will eventually undergo convergent evolution towards being a crab. Not only does this poke fun at the idea that all stories can be boiled down to the same beats, it opens up the possibility that the world Ben is travelling through exists outside of time as classic stories do. This sets up a practical application of this thesis when Ben's path intersects with rising conquistador Cisco's. In addition to good chemistry, this crossover arc leads itself to a tinge of societal commentary placed within the ongoing commentary on storytelling: the "new world" is Cisco's unknown (on the path) and Ben's known (escape from the path).

Ben appropriately faces many different trials on the path. The Hike makes it a point in its selection of trails for Ben to surmount that there's more to adventuring than being what is derogatorily known as being a "murder hobo", even if the biggest challenge along the way is to kill the big bad evil guy you were stuck doing manual labor for. Or the fact that you are armed the whole time. Likewise, the temptations that could lead Ben off the path are based in his own personal memories and/or fetishes.

The final destination Ben finds himself in is the Executive Producer's office space. It straddles the boundaries between life and death and known and unknown. The reward Ben demands out of the man he likens to God is, simply put, to answer for his crimes. In another parallel to classical mythology, the Executive Producer self-identifies as a consultant to the path itself, much like a diety would cede authority to fate itself. The path, much like the fates, chooses protagonists from a place unmoored by every other potential setting a story can have. If you want to go past leaning on the fourth wall into breaking it, this makes the path a stand-in for an author.

The final branching point in The Hike is functionally the initial branching point in The Matrix but in reverse: Ben must choose to either stay in the mystical world of the path in perpetuity and become a Producer, or return to the reality he once knew with the added burden of the Sword of Damocles dropping on him if he ever acknowledged the path he went down. Ben's solution to this dilemma is to take a page from xkcd grinding the red and blue pills together into purple cocaine and exploit the fact that the decision is made while he's still on the path; creating another version of himself so both doors can be crossed through.

In many narratives, the denouement hands audiences one final twist to take with them on the road. The surprise on deck this time is Ben connecting the dots in his head that his wife Teresa went down her own path one night long ago, making Ben's burden heavier instead of lighter as he hoped on his drive home.

Imagine sitting across the table from someone manipulating your story. Forever.
Journey Home